Who Killed Who is about "who murdered who" in each Season.
- Tyler O'Neill -- Unknown
Reason -- I think Tyler was at the "wrong place at the wrong time". Or maybe Tyler had a secret...?
- Brett Shimura -- Unknown
Reason -- This one is quite obvious; Brett was the mean-girl of Lakewood who convinced Tyler to secretly film Audrey's cafeteria scheme and Brett posted it all over social media. Two hours later, Brett returned to his house by Tyler, received terrifying text messages, got his back horizontally slashed / throat sliced open with a hunting knife, and tossed into the swimming pool. Brett was atrocious and batshit. We all know Brett was murdered because of Audrey's video, but... what if Brett was offed for having files of everyone on his laptop? Maybe he was killed because of something far worse?